I was racking my brain trying to think of where I had read this story before. Turns out that Margaret Hillert drew upon an old Grimm's fairytale, The Bremen Town Musicians, for "Four Good Friends". [And no, I had to do research and ask a bunch of people before I could 'recall' where I had read it before.]
[You can skip this part if you know the story]
In the Grimm's story a donkey, a dog, a cat, and a rooster all find themselves hitting the trail after having been let go from their respective farms. They meet on the road and decide to go to Bremen to become musicians(??). On the way a cute little house gets their attention, and when they look in the window they see robbers gloating over their ill-gotten loot. The animals, who are standing on top of one another, make a chorus of sounds which ends up scaring the robbers away.
Since possession is two-thirds of the law in fairy tales, they immediately take over the home and begin settling in. However the robbers aren't done with the place and they return after regaining their nerve. The animals soon get the better of them when one of the men sneaks into the house after dark. He is scratched by the cat, bitten by the dog, kicked by the donkey and screeched at by the rooster. He runs from the house screaming in terror that a monster has taken over the house and that all bad-guys in the area ought to clear out. The animals, having apparently found a place that's better than Bremen, live happily ever after.
[end]
Since possession is two-thirds of the law in fairy tales, they immediately take over the home and begin settling in. However the robbers aren't done with the place and they return after regaining their nerve. The animals soon get the better of them when one of the men sneaks into the house after dark. He is scratched by the cat, bitten by the dog, kicked by the donkey and screeched at by the rooster. He runs from the house screaming in terror that a monster has taken over the house and that all bad-guys in the area ought to clear out. The animals, having apparently found a place that's better than Bremen, live happily ever after.
[end]
Margaret Hillert's version begins with the sad animals lamenting that no wants them. (It's very sad actually, because Krystyna Stasiak shows the animals crying at first.) The Dog, for example, says:
I can not work.
No one wants me.
I have to go away.
Away, away, away.
Like in the original though, the animals soon meet, decide to go down the path together and find a home. [They look inside. The men see them and run away.]
Now we have a house
We have something to eat.
We do not have to work.
We are happy.
THE SKINNY:::
I like this story but must say that with this simple text that everyone's motivation isn't clear. For example, there is nothing which explains why the criminal men run away when they see the animals. They just do.
However, if you read one of the many versions of The Bremen Town Musicians first, your youngster will be able to fill in the blanks and after that, they are going to be so excited to be able to read the story for themselves that they'll just beam.
I like this story but must say that with this simple text that everyone's motivation isn't clear. For example, there is nothing which explains why the criminal men run away when they see the animals. They just do.
However, if you read one of the many versions of The Bremen Town Musicians first, your youngster will be able to fill in the blanks and after that, they are going to be so excited to be able to read the story for themselves that they'll just beam.
Pam
Somewhere in the X-burbs
- Accelerated Reading level : .07
- Pages: 31
- Publisher: Modern Curriculum Press
- ISBN-10: 0813655617
THE TECHNICAL BITS:::
61 Unique words
274 words all together
274 words all together
The most challenging words is something. The rest mainly come from the standard Margaret Hillert list (hover here).
Accelerated Reader: reading level: 0.7 / points: 0.5 / quiz: 9361











