Night Before Christmas Smack Down

Whether you call it "Twas the Night Before Christmas" or "A Visit from St. Nicholas" or "The Night Before Christmas", the 1823 poem about a visit from Santa is arguably one of America's favorite Christmas reads.

Because it is so popular, there are many versions to choose from -- not to mention the parodies -- and so to help you find your first version, or just your next, we've shifted through the comments and ratings at Goodreads, LibraryThing, and Amazon to find THE MOST POPULAR versions. All of the books below earned at least 4-Stars and family approved artwork.

NOTE: I went to update the numbers this year and found that both GoodReads and Amazon have really messed up by combining reviews .AND. giving the same numbers/star ratings to different versions of this poem.  So I'm glad I did my research last year to find the most popular version.  I've reported numbers where they seemed accurate.
 

Illustrated by Tom Browning

This is a beautifully illustrated book that has received 5-stars from Amazon readers. I think they love the beautiful old-fashioned artwork of Tom Browning.

Page Count: 48


excerpt from Tom Browning's Night Before Christmas

by Natasha Wing, Mike Lester (Illustrator)

Okay, this one isn't the classic poem, but it was awfully popular so we included it. The story is that two days before Christmas, an overworked family laments with a familiar rhyme that they had "too much to do, Our tree wasn't up yet, and Mom had the flu."

It received almost all 5-stars at Amazon, and 4.27 stars from 22 readers at Goodreads.

Reading Information:
Word Count: 543
Page Count:  32
Accelerated Reading Level: 2.8 / points: 0.5
AR quiz: 64117

--sample pages available


by Walter Wick

This is a fun picture puzzle book that has received almost all 5 stars from Amazon reader-reviewers and 4.2 stars from 75 voters at GoodReads.

Page Count: 40
Publisher: Cartwheel Books

--sample pages available

excerpt from Can You See What I See? The Night Before Christmas
(click on the image and most browsers will make it larger)


bookcover of Twas the Night Before Christmas, illustrated by Jan BrettTwas the Night Before Christmas: A Visit from St. Nicholas
by Greg Hildebrandt, Jan Brett

Love Jan Brett's intricate work and this one's a charmer.  (Amazon reviews were confused as apparently 2 different books were mingled.)

Page Count:  32
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile

--sample pages available

excerpt from Jan Brett's The Night Before Christmas


bookcover of Little Golden Book's NIGHT BEFORE CHRISTMAS The Night Before Christmas
by Little Golden Book

This is the Little Golden Book version with their usual simple, but nice drawings. 4.4 stars from 16 opinions.

Page Count: 24
 --sample pages available

Illustrated by Mary Engelbreit

Mary Engelbreit's style is very popular.

Word Count: 541
Page Count: 32
Accelerated Reading Level: 4.3 / points: 0.5
AR quiz: 45419
 --sample pages available
excerpt from Mary Engelbreit, The Night Before Christmas



Illustrated by Bruce Whatley

Bruce Whatley of "Martha Doesn't Say Sorry" fame illustrates this version.

4.3 stars from 25 people
Page Count: 40 pages
Publisher: HarperCollins


excerpt from Bruce Whatley, Night Before Christmas


Illustrated by Cheryl Harness

A different artistic style with this one.  

3.9 stars from 283 readers.

Page Count: 40
Publisher: Random House
ISBN-10: 0394826981
 --sample pages available


excerpt from Cheryl Harness, Night Before Christmasexcerpt from Cheryl Harness, Night Before Christmas



by David Davis 
illustrated by James Rice

This unusual version ranked pretty high at both sites we polled with 4-Stars.

Page Count: 32
Publisher: Pelican Publishing
 --sample pages available




Illustrated by Rachel Isadora

Love this cute version which brings a different style and perspective to the poem.  It earned 4.18 stars from 28 GoodReaders and 5 stars from Amazon reviewers.

excerpt from Rachel Isadora's Night Before Christmas

Page Count: 32
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile
 
--sample pages available 


bookcover of Night Before Christmas Pop-up by Robert Sabuda
4.9 stars from 81 folks at Amazon
The Night Before Christmas Pop-up
Artwork by Robert Sabuda

We've owned this book for about 7 years now. We bought it when our eldest was a preschooler and it has become sort of a family tradition to set up milk and cookies for Santa and our selves, and read it together on Christmas Eve.

We had to wait a few years before we could allow the children to play with it without close supervision, and maybe that is why they remain enthralled with it after all these years.

Page Count: 12
 --sample pages available


excerpt from Robert Sabuda's Night Before Christmas Pop-up book


No comments :

http://www.bloglovin.com/blog/6276921/?claim=y89bz5f8z6d